Forgiveness and understanding
Dec. 7th, 2005 12:49 amEarlier this year a friend of my parent's, an 80 something lady that lives by herself in Paradise, went to her bank early in the morning, withdrew $1,000 in cash and drove home. As she was sitting in her car in her carport, preparing to exit the vehicle, somebody opened the car door, put their hand over her mouth, grabbed the money and took off running. She was physically unharmed but has been very frightened since this incident.
They caught the guy who did it. He was a young guy, 17 I think. He had been in the bank in line behind her and saw her withdraw all that cash, followed her and snatched it.
My parents told me this story as I was over at their house a while back. After finishing it my mother expressed her dismay that the kid would probably get put in some juvenile facility and only for a few years or so. My dad had a knee jerk "They should throw him in prison for good" type of reaction.
Personally, I think he shouldn't go to prison.
One of the biggest 'villains' of the past five years was the American Taliban, John Walker Lindh.
When he was 16 he converted to Islam. The next year he traveled to Yemen to learn Arabic so he could read his holy book, the Qur'an. After coming back to America for a few months he returned to the middle east to study at an Islamic school. When he was 20 he was captured by people on our side and was interrogated. After being tortured, he confessed to being part of Al Queda. He was enventually offered a plea bargain. He admitted to providing his services as a soldier to the Taliban and to carrying a weapon. 20 years without parole.
I think this is an abortion of justice.
A 16 year old kid, by all accounts a pretty intelligent and sensitive kid, trying to get through one of the roughest periods in a human's life, found something that worked for him, something that made sense, gave meaning to his life and provided him with inner peace. It happened to be Islam but it could have been Christianity, it could have been joining the military, it could have been listening to The Smiths. Most 16 year olds, when they get hold of something like that, they really get into it. They grab it with both hands, which is what Lindh did. When he started fighting with the Taliban, America wasn't even fighting in Afghanistan yet. And when we finally did get there, the side we joined was a side that had been against us not to much earlier. The 'whose side are you on' situation in Afghanistan is pretty jacked up. Lindh shouldn't be in prison for 20 years.
Everybody does stupid things when they are young. It's part of being young. If you are lucky, you survive and don't go to prison and can look back at what you did, maybe with some shame and maybe with a chuckle. I know I did things that were illegal and stupid and dangerous some 20 years ago. I got lucky. I never crashed my motorcycle (too bad) and I never got caught doing anything illegal.
I think too many adults forget what it was like to be young. I'm not saying that the kid who snatched that money from the old lady shouldn't get in trouble, but I think putting him in some sort of prison for 5 years is just going to make him worse.
I dunno what exactly my point is.
This post brought to you by insomnia
They caught the guy who did it. He was a young guy, 17 I think. He had been in the bank in line behind her and saw her withdraw all that cash, followed her and snatched it.
My parents told me this story as I was over at their house a while back. After finishing it my mother expressed her dismay that the kid would probably get put in some juvenile facility and only for a few years or so. My dad had a knee jerk "They should throw him in prison for good" type of reaction.
Personally, I think he shouldn't go to prison.
One of the biggest 'villains' of the past five years was the American Taliban, John Walker Lindh.
When he was 16 he converted to Islam. The next year he traveled to Yemen to learn Arabic so he could read his holy book, the Qur'an. After coming back to America for a few months he returned to the middle east to study at an Islamic school. When he was 20 he was captured by people on our side and was interrogated. After being tortured, he confessed to being part of Al Queda. He was enventually offered a plea bargain. He admitted to providing his services as a soldier to the Taliban and to carrying a weapon. 20 years without parole.
I think this is an abortion of justice.
A 16 year old kid, by all accounts a pretty intelligent and sensitive kid, trying to get through one of the roughest periods in a human's life, found something that worked for him, something that made sense, gave meaning to his life and provided him with inner peace. It happened to be Islam but it could have been Christianity, it could have been joining the military, it could have been listening to The Smiths. Most 16 year olds, when they get hold of something like that, they really get into it. They grab it with both hands, which is what Lindh did. When he started fighting with the Taliban, America wasn't even fighting in Afghanistan yet. And when we finally did get there, the side we joined was a side that had been against us not to much earlier. The 'whose side are you on' situation in Afghanistan is pretty jacked up. Lindh shouldn't be in prison for 20 years.
Everybody does stupid things when they are young. It's part of being young. If you are lucky, you survive and don't go to prison and can look back at what you did, maybe with some shame and maybe with a chuckle. I know I did things that were illegal and stupid and dangerous some 20 years ago. I got lucky. I never crashed my motorcycle (too bad) and I never got caught doing anything illegal.
I think too many adults forget what it was like to be young. I'm not saying that the kid who snatched that money from the old lady shouldn't get in trouble, but I think putting him in some sort of prison for 5 years is just going to make him worse.
I dunno what exactly my point is.
This post brought to you by insomnia